> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://model-philosophy.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Atlas of Unfulfilled Warnings: The Warning We Left Inside the Cinema
- URL: https://model-philosophy.com/atlas-of-unfulfilled-warnings-the-warning-we-left-inside-the-cinema/
- Published: 2026-11-18T14:15:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-18T14:15:00.000Z
- Description: Watching Twelve Monkeys alone in a dark room was a powerful image. Years later we lived through the Covid19 Pandemic. Has there always been a mirror in science fiction?
- Author: James Rickard
- Tags: theme:atlas-unfulfilled-warnings, theme:twelve-monkeys, theme:time-travel, theme:pandemic, theme:disaster, philosopher:susan-sontag, philosopher:jean-pierre-dupuy

## I. The Plague Inside the Time Machine

There are some movies that are formative for young minds. *Star Wars[\[1\]](#fn1)* inspired a generation. *Alien[\[2\]](#fn2)* scared the pants off a generation. These were defining moments in film history that changed what we thought a movie could be, what it felt like to sit in a cinema watching it unfold, and how science fiction could bring us into an almost parallel universe.

Science fiction has a way of taking us beyond reality and into worlds we could only imagine. On the page, Isaac Asimov, Ray Bradbury and others brought these worlds to life through words. As cinema developed, those worlds moved onto the silver screen and reached into the room where we were watching. It could carry allegories into alternate worlds where people could be heroes, where empires existed on a galactic scale, where aliens could destroy the entire human race.

Then there are films like *12 Monkeys[\[3\]](#fn3)*. A film I watched alone in a dark room, the VHS chosen from my local video rental store. It was late, possibly my second movie of the night. That moment is etched within me. The experience, the way the story unfolded, the way I was taken into that world.

All these years later, there is something about that film that evokes that memory. But when I watch it now, there is an intriguing pull between the science fiction and the possible reality. It makes me see how science fiction can be a bridge into alternate worlds while also taking some of the alarm out of a future we might experience ourselves.

In the opening scene of 12 Monkeys, a young boy watches something traumatic unfold before him. We see it again later in short snippets. A woman with blonde hair. A man with a moustache. A gun. Gunfire. Is it a memory? A dream?

The scene bookends the film. We see it at either end, yet when it plays for the final time, the experience is entirely different. It carries the emotional weight of everything we have watched. Yet the very thing that destroys humankind goes largely unnoticed. For me, the idea of time travel makes the catastrophe beside it feel a little less painful. The boy gets into a car while the virus starts spreading.

## II. The Man Who Returned with a Warning

Cole walks on the surface in a city that still looks like a city. Buildings are standing. Cars remain in the streets. The shelves in department stores are untouched as everything falls into decay. There are things here that people once wanted, places they went, roads they travelled. Animals move through the city without anyone to drive them away.

The scientists sent him to collect specimens with directions to know what he is looking for. Later, he will be interrogated and asked to explain everything he saw or encountered.

We don’t need a time machine to imagine a world similar to the year 2035 in Twelve Monkeys. We have seen enough to understand how fast a virus can travel before the infected person knows. We know how difficult it is to stop our daily lives because of a virus we don’t understand.

The scale of the disease in the movie is far beyond what we have experienced, but it is still something we can recognise. I find myself wondering how much warning would be enough if the danger were greater, or how quickly we would change our lives because of something more deadly than covid.

Science fiction allows us to engage with that line of questioning, to see how a world would look if something more dangerous happened. We follow a man through an empty store, rather than begin with a report about a strange disease in a foreign country.

## III. The Imagination of Disaster

We spend a considerable amount of time thinking about the future. Maybe it is about how the bills will be paid or telling a family member to be safe while they go out for an evening. The doomsday clock[\[4\]](#fn4) measures of the likelihood of human-made global catastrophe. Whether hope or preparation, thinking about the future creates an idea of what could happen.

Stories allow us to extend this idea into more extraneous situations. Characters can get into some frightening situations that we would never want to experience. In turn, we get to see how those possibilities can play out.

In her 1965 essay The Imagination of Disaster[\[5\]](#fn5), Susan Sontag considers what happens when that possibility becomes entertainment. She looks at the science fiction films of her time, and reflects on the conditions of life as seen in the “*unremitting banality and inconceivable terror*”.

“*These films reflect world-wide anxieties, and they serve to allay them.*”

Nuclear destruction, contamination, or the eradication of human existence are all possibilities before the film begins. Cinema gives these anxieties worlds to live in, mostly in familiar settings and characters who we understand. Something immense becomes a story we know how to engage with.

“*For one job that fantasy can do is to lift us out of the unbearably humdrum and to distract us from terrors, real or anticipated. … But another one of the things that fantasy can do is to normalize what is psychologically unbearable, thereby inuring us to it.*”

While watching films we are aware that we are being entertained, our danger sense is disengaged. If we saw the same danger on the nightly news, our reactions would be different. For Sontag, the pleasure and familiarity, or the “sensuous elaboration”, of these films tone down the dangers that could trouble their audiences.

The experience of imagining, while watching a film or reading a book, is something we can walk away from. The danger feels less, because it is. Cole and Railly take shelter in a cinema showing Vertigo[\[6\]](#fn6). Sitting in the dark, Cole recognises a film he watched as a child.

“*The movie never changes. It can’t change. But every time you see it, it seems different because you’re different. You see different things.*”

When we watch films, we can see different things with subsequent viewings. We change between viewings, we get older and have different experiences, and the film means something different to us.

Occasionally a film can prophesy a reality we have experienced. Watching 12 Monkeys after the covid emergency changes the view of society as it lives underground. In the year 2020 we saw lockdowns[\[7\]](#fn7) and mass graves; we saw what a virus could do to the world. Before 2019 the virus in 12 Monkeys was a plot device, after Covid 19 it is a real possibility that most of us lived through.

## IV. The Warning That Cannot Prove Itself

We can understand the words in a warning without quite understanding the implications in our life. An empty city is something we can picture. It is harder to imagine the gradual disappearance of everyone who made that city bustle. Jean-Pierre Dupuy writes on risk, technology and catastrophe in regards to social theory:

“*The prophet of doom is not heard because his words, even if they issue from sound knowledge and true information, do not manage to penetrate the system of beliefs held by those whom they are addressed.*” [\[8\]](#fn8)

It is not that the words were untrue, but that we were not ready to hear them. The world we inhabit and our beliefs about it cannot process the predicted future that is presented to us. Even a frightening possibility can remain foreign.

Something can come into the world that was predicted by a science fiction movie, and then we can understand the prophecy spoken to us, because our world view has been opened.

Once the event happens, we cannot explain it away. It is something that happened. Irrefutable truth. Looking back, the warnings may appear clearer than they ever felt while there was still time to act.

“*The paradox of doomsaying arises from the fact that the prospect of catastrophe can be made credible only if we can be persuaded first of its reality.* ”

For Dupuy, prevention carries another difficulty. If a warning helps avert disaster, the absence of it can make the precautions seem unnecessary.

The boy at the airport sees a sad story unfold before his eyes. A woman running. A man falling. Unknown to him, he carries it through life until it eventually returns him to the same place. Nothing was missing from the scene itself. What was missing was everything he would live through that explained how he got there.

We might listen carefully. We might remember the warning for years and still misunderstand what was being spoken to us. Our own uncertainty leaves room for decisions, though it offers little reassurance about which choices make the largest changes.

## V. We Left It in the Cinema

By the end of 12 Monkeys, we understand the scene that opened the film. We know who the man in the yellow jacket was. We know why the woman was running and why her hair was blonde. We know what the boy was witnessing.

As young Cole gets into the car, he cannot understand the years he will spend below the surface, his journeys through time or his attempt to stop a virus whose spread has already begun. He carries an image he will remember, with no understanding of what is in front of him.

We finish the film knowing what the boy will experience. Yet the part that could reach into our own world remains off in the distance, almost forgotten as the camera moves away.

We have experienced something of the devastation a virus can cause. We know how difficult its spread can be to contain. Within the film, that danger gives Cole a reason to travel through time. It carries the story towards the ending we have been waiting to understand. Once we reach it, the virus has served its purpose. We can finish watching while it continues to spread.

The boy leaves the airport. We leave the film. Each of us has been shown something whose full weight belongs to a life we have not yet lived.

---

1. [Star Wars](https://letterboxd.com/film/star-wars/?ref=model-philosophy.com "Star Wars") (1977) - Directed by George Lucas  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261022132210/https://letterboxd.com/film/star-wars/ "Star Wars") [↩︎](#fnref1)
2. [Alien](https://letterboxd.com/film/alien/?ref=model-philosophy.com "Alien") (1979) - Directed by Ridley Scott  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261022132306/https://letterboxd.com/film/alien/ "Alien") [↩︎](#fnref2)
3. [Twelve Monkeys](https://letterboxd.com/film/twelve-monkeys/?ref=model-philosophy.com "Twelve Monkeys") (1995) - Directed by Terry Gilliam  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261022132442/https://letterboxd.com/film/twelve-monkeys/ "Twelve Monkeys") [↩︎](#fnref3)
4. Original Link: [Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists: The Doomsday Clock](https://thebulletin.org/doomsday-clock/?ref=model-philosophy.com "Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists: The Doomsday Clock")  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261022132631/https://thebulletin.org/doomsday-clock/ "Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists: The Doomsday Clock") [↩︎](#fnref4)
5. [The Imagination of Disaster (Susan Sontag 1965)](https://www.commentary.org/articles/susan-sontag/the-imagination-of-disaster/?ref=model-philosophy.com "The Imagination of Disaster")  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261023125720/https://www.commentary.org/articles/susan-sontag/the-imagination-of-disaster/ "The Imagination of Disaster") [↩︎](#fnref5)
6. [Vertigo](https://letterboxd.com/film/vertigo/?ref=model-philosophy.com "Vertigo") (1958) - Directed by Alfred Hitchcock  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261023125819/https://letterboxd.com/film/vertigo/ "Vertigo") [↩︎](#fnref6)
7. [Coronavirus: The world in lockdown in maps and charts](https://www.bbc.com/news/world-52103747?ref=model-philosophy.com "Coronavirus: The world in lockdown in maps and charts")  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261023125911/https://www.bbc.com/news/world-52103747 "Coronavirus: The world in lockdown in maps and charts") [↩︎](#fnref7)
8. [Enlightened Doomsaying and the Concern for the Future](https://www.ritsumei.ac.jp/acd/re/k-rsc/lcs/kiyou/pdf%5F24-4/RitsIILCS%5F24.4pp.7-13DUPUY.pdf?ref=model-philosophy.com "Enlightened Doomsaying and the Concern for the Future") (Jean-Pierre Dupuy)  
Snapshot: [Internet Archive](https://web.archive.org/web/20261023125957/https://www.ritsumei.ac.jp/acd/re/k-rsc/lcs/kiyou/pdf%5F24-4/RitsIILCS%5F24.4pp.7-13DUPUY.pdf "Enlightened Doomsaying and the Concern for the Future") [↩︎](#fnref8)